Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Beth Adams's avatar

Amitava, it makes me very happy that you've not only done what you said you wanted to do -- start drawing -- but made it a practice that helps you "feel more alive." Of course you are an artist, because you do this, with dedication and purpose -- but I also like your insistence on being an amateur. This is how I feel about music. I've done it all my life, I practice, I play and sing with others, some of whom are professional, but I myself remain an amateur and am glad of it. And nothing makes me feel more alive than making music, even art -- because the latter is my "profession."

Expand full comment
Mira Kamdar's avatar

My grandfather used those five-year diaries for years. Unfortunately, he was not a writer and what he recorded was very basic daily stuff, like what they ate, a trip to the hardware store, a birthday celebration but with no description. He was a literal-minded man who had to drop out of school after 8th grade to help on the family farm. But he yearned for literature: Accumulating a library of books of which he was immensely proud in (self-taught) Spanish, Norwegian and the English and Danish he grew up with. He also, in the Danish tradition, wrote poems for family members to commemorate graduations, birthdays and anniversaries. They aren't very good poems but he wrote them. I treasure the one he wrote for my PhD from Berkeley.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...

No posts