Beat the Heat
Also: Too Late for Hate
Newspapers in my town carried ads on how to beat the heat. But what to do about hate?
The Guardian has published an op-ed by me on the elections in India. “The electorate has resurrected a viable opposition in parliament against a chastened BJP. But neither side is ready to face the immensity of the climate crisis.” I’m going to cut and paste the piece here below for easier access:
The hidden story behind India’s remarkable election results: lethal heat
A polling official in Varanasi last Thursday. Photograph: Priyanshu Singh/Reuters
The Bharatiya Janata party (BJP), led by India’s prime minister, Narendra Modi, has won more seats than the opposition alliance, and yet its victory tastes of defeat. Why?
In the days leading to the election, the BJP’s main slogan had been Abki baar, 400 Paar, a call to voters to send more than 400 of its candidates to the 543-member parliament. This slogan, voiced by Modi at his campaign rallies, set a high bar for the party. Most exit polls had predicted a massive victory for the BJP – and now the results, with that party having won only 240 seats, suggest that the electorate has sent a chastening message to the ruling party and trimmed its hubris.Let’s take as an example what has happened in the Faizabad constituency.
Faizabad, in the state of Uttar Pradesh, also includes the city of Ayodhya. Back in January, Modi inaugurated, with tremendous fanfare and pomp, a temple built on the site where a Hindu mob had demolished a 16th-century mosque. The opening of the temple had not only brought to fruition a three-decade-old promise of the BJP, it also cemented the notion of India as a Hindu majoritarian state.
The inaugural ceremonies were led by Modi, and he stood inside the temple, in its sanctum sanctorum, with the head of the militantly ultranationalist Hindu group Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). Modi called that moment “the beginning of a new era”, but to many it signified the end of the secular ideals behind the idea of India.
And yet, one of the most significant outcomes in this election has been the defeat of the BJP candidate in Ayodhya. It was not the inauguration of the temple and the televised spectacle attended by celebrities that mattered in the end; instead, it was the more pressing issues of unemployment and price rise that the voters cared about. A survey spread across 19 of India’s 28 states showed that while 22% of the people felt that the temple was the Modi government’s “most liked” action, only 8% said that it was their primary concern. In contrast, unemployment was the primary concern for 27% of those surveyed.
You wouldn’t know this if you heard the hype in India’s television studios, where enthusiastic anchors mirrored Modi’s aggressive statements, particularly his hostile and bigoted remarks about Muslims – but there was no Modi wave. There was only the heatwave. Just this week, in my hometown of Patna, in eastern India, I met a man named Ashutosh Pandey who told me that the level of heat had proved fatal for people in his own village: he wasn’t going to risk voting, and neither was his mother.
People in Patna voted on 1 June, the last day of the seven-phase polling schedule. In Patna, the temperature had hovered above 40C. Local newspapers carried government ads exhorting voters to exercise their franchise, as well as half-page ads from the health ministry offering advice about how to avoid heatstroke. In the days leading to the voting in Patna, there were reports of personnel at polling stations dying from the heat. In the nation’s capital, Delhi, there were protests over water shortages. Last week, the temperature in Delhi hit 49.9C.
One could say that the overbearing, unendurable heat was an obstacle to democracy because it was impossible for many – especially those who are poor, need to earn their livelihood or are without means of travel – to contemplate standing in a line to vote.
The crucial point to be noted here is that the heat did not figure at all among the thundering sentiments delivered from the dais by the candidates. The prominent environmentalist Ashish Kothari told me that the “full dimensions of the climate crisis” had escaped both the BJP’s and Congress’s manifestos. In the face of such silence, it fell on the Delhi High Court to warn of the effects of global warming this past week: The court warned that Delhi could soon turn into “a barren desert.”
Perhaps the election results hold a small promise of change. The Indian electorate has resurrected a viable opposition in the parliament – a possibility that had seemed remote when the television channels were forecasting an inevitable and overwhelming BJP triumph. There might still be drama in store with shifting alliances in the coming days. But all of this will appear ordinary, maybe banal, and certainly irresponsible and deadly, when the effects of overheating and water shortage spread through India.
The truth about climate change is that it exacerbates social inequities, and once multiple crises begin to unfold in the future, one of the first victims will be the faith in democracy that we are all experiencing in this heady moment.
*************************************************************************************************************
Thanks for reading my piece. In an hour I’m leaving for the airport and am headed to New York. On June 8, I will be participating in the Beacon Litfest. I was lucky to arrive at my friend Ravish’s house just as the election results were coming in on Tuesday, June 4. He delivered seven or eight video reports in eloquent Hindi, a few of them extempore, his remarks both incisive and charged with metaphors. Before leaving his home that evening, I asked Ravish for a statement on what was happening. Here is what he wrote in Hindi; I have translated it in English below.
"With all their remaining strength, the common people have built an opposition and erected our parliament. This creation of the opposition is the people's mandate. 2024 has given a gift to Bapu's and Babasaheb Ambedkar's dreams for our democracy. It has given us an opposition." Ravish Kumar
*************************************************************************************************************
I spent my last day in India during this visit signing books at Bahrisons, Faqir Chand, Midland Books South Ex, and Kunzum in GK II. Get your copies from those bookstores as well as The Bookshop in Jor Bagh that hosted a wonderful event last night (with the star translator Arunava Sinha engaging me in a conversation about craft and the writing of My Beloved Life). I met so many wonderful readers at the packed event at The Bookshop. Truly touched by all that love.
You have captured the sense and relief on the election results beautifully, atleast for some of us. Sadly, the heat kept me indoors and I missed the very interesting session with two As. Thankfully, Noida voted in the early phase when the summer heat was bearable enough for most of us to take a morning walk to the polling station to vote.
Unfortunately was not in Delhi but would have loved to attend the discussion at The Bookshop. Next time perhaps. 🤞